Restaurant review: Andrew Edmunds, Soho

It is, as I’ve said before, potentially impossible to choose where to review in London, a city of infinite variety with new restaurants opening every week, bucking the national trend of gloom and existential despair. More than one city, really, with microclimate after microclimate, from Hackney to Soho, Peckham to Brixton, Borough to Chelsea and beyond. And that’s before we get to all the bits beloved of Vittles, the parts close to the North Circular, or far from a Tube station.

So whenever I despair of being a Reading-based restaurant blog, I remind myself that it could be worse: imagine the paralysis-inducing task of having to choose a London restaurant to review every week. Worse even than that, I could be in a soulless hellscape, like Dubai.

As it is I review a London restaurant three or four times a year, so I have the luxury of being able to pick and choose places that genuinely appeal to me. I do, however, have two rules of thumb which I find very useful in narrowing down the number of restaurants under consideration.

The first is that I don’t review somewhere that has been reviewed by Practically Every Broadsheet Critic. Because really, who cares? You would think only about twenty-five restaurants open in London every year if you were to go by the national press, because as I’ve pointed out before, they all descend on the same ones in a short space of time.

Look at it this way: we have 6 national restaurant critics, although at most only 5 will review any particular restaurant, because Giles Coren and Camilla Long at the Times and Sunday Times divvy them up between them. Nonetheless Oudh 1722, the new Indian restaurant in Borough from multi-Michelin-starred chef (and employer of atrocious copywriters) Aktar Islam has been reviewed by 5 out of 6. So has Simpson’s In The Strand: Jeremy King opening a new place is a big deal, and he has a lot of influential friends in hospitality.

But it goes on and on, and every week if you look at the broadsheets the same names keep cropping up. Kid; Osteria Vibrato; Burro; Chez Rose; Appalachia; The Latimer; Cloth Cornhill; Cafe Clement; Impala. Are these places serving the best food in London? Possibly, possibly not. Do they have the most effective PR? Abso-bloody-lutely. And in a way you can’t win: if all the reviewers praise a restaurant in unison – as they nearly always do – you might say it’s a little fishy. On the other hand, if one steps out of line and says a place is mediocre you wonder if it’s true, or if they’re mostly saying it to stand out from the crowd.

A better solution would be for our motley crew of hereditary columnists and broadsheet lifers to seek out the genuinely interesting, but for whatever reason they don’t do that. And I shouldn’t necessarily complain about that: perhaps if they did the likes of Vittles wouldn’t exist, and more pertinently nor would restaurant blogs.

Anyway, the upshot is that I don’t bother with that kind of restaurant: perhaps in a couple of years, if they stay the course, they might be interesting to me. Besides, the last time I went somewhere that was shiny and new, that attracted universal acclaim, it was Town in Covent Garden and, genuinely, it really wasn’t all that. But the owner and the chef were both well connected: the hype machine did its job.

The second set of restaurants I rule out are any that have given free food to either of London’s most prominent content creators.

Now, bearing in mind my New Year’s Resolution not to slate influencers I am going to pick my words carefully, but here goes. There are two content creators called James Dimitri and Bite Twice who have done a sterling job of fooling people into thinking that they are fearless and honest food reviewers who never accept payment for a review and can one hundred per cent be trusted not to mince their words.

How do they do this, you might ask? Well, it’s simple. They pay their own money to eat at all manner of cheap places: a greasy spoon here, a chippy in the middle of Metroland there. They scoff a £5 lamb wrap from Enfield or a bánh mì from Bermondsey. And then, having cultivated a reputation for being utterly unflinching about cheap scran, in come the freebies, from Michelin starred or Michelin adjacent restaurants.

The word invite – never AD – is hidden away in lower case, right at the bottom of a long caption. They rely on people being too gullible to notice, too credulous to realise that “never paid” is simply untrue if you’re being paid in free meals. Depressingly, I think it works.

So breathless captions like Possibly the best dining experience we have ever had or Is X worthy of the hype?, Is this Manchester’s best restaurant? or – here he is again – Is the £130 feast menu from 2 Michelin star chef Aktar Islam’s ‘Oudh’ worth it? all, sadly, invite the same answer. How would you know? You didn’t pay. Bite Twice’s most recent free meal, at the time of writing, was to celebrate one of them getting engaged. Classy stuff.

And funnily enough those places always turn out to be “worthy of the hype”. After all, those reviews are very much part of the hype, not separate from it. Because you might bite free food twice but you would never bite the hand that feeds, not even once. Those PR firms need to be kept sweet, or the invites will dry up. But it doesn’t matter, does it? Everything is transparent and up front, and everybody knows who’s paying for what. Honest.

So that rules out a whole bunch of other restaurants. True story: I keep a note on my phone, and whenever I see a restaurant bunging a freebie to one of that gang I pop it on the blacklist and resolve to review somewhere else. Call it research, call it pettiness, call it a bit of both: you’re probably right about that. It’s a shame, I guess, that I’ll never get to review the likes of Fallow, or Cassette, or Frog by Adam Handling, or Oudh 1722, but it’s really not the end of the world. They definitely don’t need any coverage from me, and there are so many appealing places to go in London that their poor choice of bedfellows just makes my job easier.

So this week, you get a review of Soho institution Andrew Edmunds, which sails past both of my self-induced rules. It opened over forty years ago, in the townhouse adjacent to the eponymous owner’s print shop, and is still going strong today despite Edmunds’ death in 2022. You will struggle to find a content creator coming here, because they are about the shiny and new, and Andrew Edmunds is almost certainly older than they are.

It’s not been around, been forgotten and then enjoyed a renaissance: it’s not that kind of place. It has always been there, like the house in Up as Soho has evolved and changed around it. And actually even that isn’t entirely true: the Georgian townhouse that’s home to the restaurant is over 300 years old. In those terms it’s a Johnny-come-lately, in London restaurant terms it’s positively venerable.

So no influencers, but what about restaurant critics? Well again, Andrew Edmunds has been around so long that barely anyone notices them doing their thing: like some kind of Halley’s Comet a critic will review it once a decade, usually to prove that they’re keeping it real. In 2015 that was Marina O’Loughlin in the Guardian, the doyenne of the performative review. “I love this place, but not necessarily for its food,” she confided. “It’s all, apart from slightly stale bread, perfectly acceptable.”

And then three years ago Charlotte Ivers went there for the Sunday Times. “Technically perfect” was her more enthusiastic but probably less informed verdict. Both reviews mainly talked about Old Soho and New Soho and Whether Soho Isn’t What It Used To Be, because that’s what broadsheet readers like and it uses up a fair chunk of your word count. Hark at me: here I am wasting a fair amount of mine chattering on about these people of no consequence. Let’s get down to business.

The dining room, a door and a world away from the Stygian façade and dark-painted window frames, is quite a wonderful space. I’d asked for a table on the ground floor and I liked that room the best, but it was hard to get a handle on. Like the restaurant in general, it managed to conjure a feeling of having been there forever and being dated, all at once. I was lunching with my old friend Dave, and he was particularly struck by the wood chip wallpaper (“I’m pretty sure we had this at home”, he said). That had definitely been there for ages, because woe betide anybody who tried to remove it.

But beyond those faintly yellowing walls, it was all little tables, cramped wooden benches, diners packed in perhaps closer than they might like. Andrew Edmunds is often referred to as one of London’s most romantic restaurants – I’ve known Dave for nearly 35 years but I still would have told him not to get any ideas – but what they’re really doing, I think, is upselling cramped and cosy.

But it did have a certain magic, in the way that idiosyncratic hospitality businesses do. The most obvious comparison, which might have just been down to the uncomfortable pews, was Quality Chop House, but I would have been equally unsurprised, heading out the door into the chill at the end of my meal, to find myself on the Île Saint-Louis.

But just to say something relatable to my patient Reading readers: see that bar, past all the tables? A little bit of this space – just a little, mind – also reminded me of Reading’s very own Sweeney & Todd. Both restaurants are roughly the same vintage, too: the main difference is that the owners of Andrew Edmunds haven’t spent the last 10 years or so looking to sell their restaurant for an overvalued price while simultaneously trying to insist that any buyer keep it exactly as it is. Even from my time in Andrew Edmunds, I could more easily see why people could feel committed to its preservation.

Andrew Edmunds, like its Soho peers Quo Vadis, The French House and even The Devonshire, does that whole handwritten menu daily thing, and arriving on that Friday lunchtime I was disappointed to see that the dishes I’d been steadily tracking all week had come off in time for our visit: no skate wing with fennel, no crabmeat piled onto toasted focaccia (ironically, both were back on the menu a couple of days later). This meant that it was, in relative terms, harder to get excited about than I’d expected. It is, however, incredibly reasonable by W1 standards. Only a couple of starters were north of a tenner, none of the mains exceeded £30.

All that and a handful of specials too made me think that, even if dishes didn’t leap out at me, I was likely to have a very good meal here. I sipped a Chambéryzette (a thoroughly unseasonal aperitif something like a strawberry vermouth) like the milquetoast I undoubtedly am, and Dave had a Lucky Saint. Even on the alcohol-free beer he was infinitely more masculine than me.

Normally I try to order differently from my dining companion, but something on the menu leapt out at both of us. Confit duck Caesar salad. I mean, how could you not? I love a Caesar salad and it’s never occurred to me that it could be improved still further by replacing the chicken with confit duck, but once I realised somebody had dreamt this up I couldn’t sit idly by and not validate their inventiveness.

And that would have been wonderful if it had been a confit duck Caesar salad. But it just wasn’t. If you think of the components of a Caesar – that dressing, anchovies, croutons, some Parmesan – literally none of them were present here. There was a tangle of bitter leaves, in a dressing lacking that saltiness, no croutons or cheese at all. Nary an anchovy to be seen, either. Instead of all those things, that ever-present of no Caesar salad ever, the cornichon: chopped very finely and distributed very meanly.

Even the confit duck was lacking saltiness or crunch, any crispy skin or texture. You know when people say of a random meat that it tastes just like chicken. This tasted just like chicken, really. It might as well have been. So no salt, no vinegar. At first I wondered if this was me recovering from a cold, and that someone else would find the flavours vivid. But Dave was as fit as a fiddle and as unmoved as me.

In the run up to writing this review I checked the most recent menu on the restaurant’s website and they’re now offering a dish called confit duck, chicory, cornichons and mustard dressing. Now, that – that is what I actually ate when I lunched at Andrew Edmunds. But if it had said that on the menu that day, if it had been accurately billed, I would have ordered something else.

“Can I ask you a question?” said a charming gentleman at the happy, lively table on our left. “Do you recommend the confit duck Caesar salad?”

“If I had my time again I’d have gone for the smoked mackerel.”

But even that smoked mackerel was the second choice wasn’t great. There was a carrot soup, yet another burrata dish, or smoked ox tongue. It all felt a little beige.

Things improved for our main courses, especially for Dave. He adored his leviathan pork chop, served on Tokyo turnips and heritage carrots, with a thin jus and with a potent dollop of mostarda. This is more firmly in Quality Chop House territory and was a big hit, and the forkful I tried bore out that Dave had chosen very well. £27.50 for this is, I would say, decent value, and if I’d ordered this I suspect the mark at the bottom might have been a smidge higher.

Dave surprised himself by clearing his plate. Dave identifies as the kind of person who orders a dish like this honestly believing he might not eat the pork fat. I, on the other hand, identify as the sort who orders a dish like this in the full knowledge that I’ll do precisely that. Between us, we’re probably the stuff of a nursery rhyme.

My dish, cod with braised leeks, was another exploration of the genre of burnished dead animal on top of some veg with jus and a splodge. If that makes Andrew Edmunds sound slightly one note that might be because it was, or maybe we just picked two dishes that, like Dave and I as people, were very much variations on a theme. And again, I liked my dish but I wondered if it was just a little bit muted, not robust enough.

The fish was halfway perfect. What you want from a piece of fish like this is the flesh to be spot on and the skin to be spot on: the former falling gently into pearlescent flakes and the latter brittle, salted and a contrasting treat. And the flesh was there, it was just the skin that was flaccid and a little underwhelming. The braised leeks were delicious, the blackened, roasted cauliflower nutty and nice enough. But again, being fussy, if there were going to be two veg in this dish I’d have liked one of them to be green, to provide contrast. And the tapenade, which was the one thing that could lift and accent everything on the plate, was too one-dimensional for the task.

This was, make no mistake about it, a pleasant plate of food. But it’s all relative: if I’d had this at the Magdalen Arms I’d probably have thought it was fine. If it had turned up at London Street Brasserie or Thames Lido I might even have said either of those establishments was having a good day. But here? I don’t know. I expected more. I will say though that the potatoes, the Cornish mids we had with our mains were hefty, crunchy of perimeter, salty and a proper joy. In this at least there were definitely echoes of Quality Chop House: this place knows what to do with a spud.

And yet I could see why people fall under the spell of this cramped, dated purveyor of beigeness, despite some of the bum notes and that wood chip wallpaper. Because even if my arse was slightly going to sleep on the bench the rest of me was wide awake. This felt like a lovely shared experience, all these tables eating and laughing, the sharp coldness of the Soho air shut out for a couple of hours.

One of my disappointments of this meal was not being able to attack the wine list: this had originally been planned as a lunch for one, the kind I wrote about last week, and Andrew Edmunds not only has a wine list whose breadth and generosity of markups has become a thing of legend but also offers an excellent range of half bottles. But when it came to it I was still recovering from my cold, Dave is no wine drinker and we had plans for a pub later on, so I just nursed a very pleasant glass of Riesling. I didn’t feel sprightly enough, at the time, to even feel like I was missing out.

Maybe there was no pleasing me that day because the short dessert menu also brought out an attack of the mehs in me. All a bit boarding school dinners, and no amount of poached kumquat was going to jazz up rice pudding enough to make me crave it. Dave was thoroughly delighted with his choice though, a stout cake taking the place of sticky pudding but still moated with an outrageously glossy toffee sauce and topped with a ball of vanilla ice cream. He loved this, he loved his glass of thick, treacly Pedro Ximenez with it.

In a world where you could be more me or be more Dave, even I would encourage you to be more Dave about this. I think he loved his meal, whereas I more wish I had.

But happily, my dessert worked out too. They had two flavours of ice cream on offer – not the vanilla, which is ring fenced for the stout cake – and when they announced brown butter and rum and raisin I think they expected me to go for one of each. But raisin isn’t my bag, so I lucked out with two orbs of gorgeous ice cream with a relatively subtle, complex taste of brown butter, transcending notions of sweet and savoury and aspiring instead, as we all should, to be interesting.

It wasn’t perfect, but even I can overlook a few ice crystals here and there when the flavour is so accomplished and imaginative. £6.50 for this, and no complaints.

Service was brilliant and completely in keeping with everything else: affable, haphazard, frazzled but impossible to dislike. Our bill came to £147, including a 12.5% service charge, and when we tried to round it up our server tried to take our payment, just couldn’t, had to refund it, tried to work out how we could pay them more and gave up. It hadn’t seemed like an especially busy service, but I hadn’t been keeping track of the people traipsing in and taking tables in the basement.

But none of that mattered, and I don’t know why. The wood chip wallpaper didn’t matter, the deceptively bland non-Caesar salad didn’t matter, the slightly generic mains didn’t matter and the fact that by 3pm I could barely feel my buttocks, that didn’t matter either. A restaurant, like a person, doesn’t reach the age of 40 without learning a trick or two. I wish at 40 I’d have been half as difficult to take exception to as Andrew Edmunds: even past 50 I’m nowhere near, and I doubt I’ll ever get there.

The rest of my day was lovely. Dave and I took a long, chilly walk across London, because chatting on a long walk is something we’ve been doing for over 30 years, and we wound up in the Dovetail, Farringdon’s gorgeous Belgian pub which had countless Westmalle beers on tap. We made inroads into them, we reminisced and looked forward, we almost certainly both talked utter nonsense. Because the lesson of my sermon this week is that friendships, and restaurants, that last for several decades have much about them to celebrate, even if some of that is only appreciated fully by the people in them.

Would I go back to Andrew Edmunds, with Quality Chop House across the way and The French House around the corner? Maybe not, and maybe that’s why they don’t bribe content creators or attract the attention of critics. Am I delighted that it exists in London and that I can say I’ve been? Certainly. And this review might make you want to go, so you can also have an experience like mine. If it does, I don’t think you’d regret that: this wasn’t the best meal I’ve had this year, but I don’t regret it either.

Andrew Edmunds – 7.7
46 Lexington St, London, W1F 0LP
020 74375708

https://www.andrewedmunds.com

Since January 2025, Edible Reading is partly supported by subscribers – click here if you want to read more about that, or click below to subscribe. By doing so you enable me to carry on doing what I do, and you also get access to subscriber only content. Whether you’re a subscriber or not, thanks for reading.

One thought on “Restaurant review: Andrew Edmunds, Soho”

  1. Gaynor Smith's avatar Gaynor Smith

    Next time you are looking for inspiration in London please could you consider Imads Syrian Restaurant in Kingley Court ( itself a very interesting place ) Very tasty food and pleasant service at a very reasonable price for central London. In addition Imad has an interesting back story.

    In the meantime maybe I’ll give Andrew Edmunds a go !

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.